Best Pizza Places in Toms River, NJ
Blaze Breaks Out at Ocean View Restaurant in Seaside Heights
January 1, 2026
Top Attractions to Explore in Ocean County, New Jersey
January 2, 2026Best Pizza Places in Toms River, NJ
Best Pizza Places in Toms River, NJ
Here are some of the best pizza places in Toms River, NJ — from highly rated local favorites to spots with standout pies (both classic and unique). Many of these are beloved by locals and food-review sites alike:
🍕 Top Local Pizza Favorites
Slice House – A local favorite with strong reviews for classic New Jersey slices and specialty pies.
PaciDough’s Pizza Joint – Well-reviewed and even featured on pizza review circuits; locals praise the pies here.
Toms River
Pondrelli's Pizza And Kitchen – – Fantastic classic Italian pizza and Italian dishes with positive local buzz.
🍕 Classic & Local Institutions
Mia's Pizza Toms River NJ – Very popular with locals and visitors alike, known for great crust and toppings.
Naples Pizza & Restaurant – A staple in town with a strong reputation for consistent quality.
Shore News Network
Schiano's Pizza – Long-standing favorite with a loyal following.
Sal's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria – Old-school Italian pizzas and hearty pies.
Villaggio Pizza Toms River – Well-liked neighborhood pizza spot with solid reviews.
🍕 Other Great Options to Try
Italy's Best III – Local choice with solid ratings.
Johnny G's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria – Popular Italian-American pizzeria.
STR Pizza – Great reviews for custom pizzas.
Mangia Brick Oven Pizza – Brick oven style favorites.
Patricia’s Of Toms River – Italian spot with pizza options and good atmosphere.
