Thanksgiving is just around the corner, and if there’s one thing that deserves a spot on every holiday table, it’s a delicious homemade-style pie! Whether you’re a fan of traditional pumpkin pie, apple crumb, pecan, blueberry, or something a little different, Ocean County has plenty of bakeries and local favorites worth checking out.

Instead of spending hours baking in the kitchen, why not let the local experts handle dessert? From longtime Jersey Shore bakeries to family-owned farm markets, here are some places to consider when shopping for your Thanksgiving pies in Ocean County.

1. Mueller’s Bakery – Bay Head

A Jersey Shore favorite since 1890, Mueller’s Bakery is a popular destination for anyone with a sweet tooth. Located in Bay Head, this longtime bakery is famous for its crumb cake, pastries, and seasonal baked goods.

For Thanksgiving, seasonal pie selections have included traditional apple, pumpkin, and harvest crumble. It’s a great place to check when looking for something special to bring to the holiday table.

Location: 80 Bridge Avenue, Bay Head, NJ

Website: muellersbakery.com

2. Emery’s Farm – New Egypt

If you’re looking for fresh-baked pies with a country bakery feel, Emery’s Farm is a must-visit. This New Egypt favorite has become well-known throughout Ocean County for its homemade baked goods.

Some of the bakery’s popular pie offerings include blueberry crumb, pecan, and caramel apple walnut. Emery’s has also been recognized by local residents as a favorite destination for pie.

Don’t forget to browse the farm market for other seasonal treats!

3. 502 Baking Company – Brick

Located on Brick Boulevard, 502 Baking Company is another local bakery worth adding to your Thanksgiving dessert shopping list.

Known for its scratch-style baked goods, the bakery offers a variety of desserts, including pies, cakes, cookies, and specialty treats. Its key lime pie is particularly popular among customers.

It’s worth contacting the bakery to ask about its Thanksgiving pie selection and holiday ordering availability.

4. Anna Banana’s Bakery – Manahawkin

For Southern Ocean County residents, Anna Banana’s Bakery is another great option for Thanksgiving desserts.

The bakery’s 2026 Thanksgiving ordering menu features an impressive selection of pies, including:

• Pumpkin pie
• Apple crumb pie
• Apple lattice pie
• Pecan pie
• Coconut cream pie
• Banana cream pie
• Cherry crumb pie
• Key lime pie
• Blueberry crumb pie

There are also vegan and gluten-free options available on the holiday menu.

Location: 657 E. Bay Avenue, Manahawkin, NJ

Website: annabananasbakerynj.com

5. Waretown Bakery – Waretown

Waretown Bakery is a longtime neighborhood bakery offering a variety of freshly baked treats.

From traditional pastries and donuts to seasonal desserts and holiday baked goods, this is another local business worth checking out before Thanksgiving.

Call ahead to ask about available whole pies and holiday specials.

Location: 586 Route 9, Waretown, NJ

6. Coastal Confections – Toms River

If you’re in Toms River, Coastal Confections is another local bakery to put on your holiday shopping list.

This downtown bakery specializes in custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and other specialty desserts. Its Thanksgiving offerings include seasonal pies, cheesecakes, breads, and other holiday treats.

It’s a great option for anyone looking to add something sweet and special to their Thanksgiving spread.

Location: 11 Washington Street, Toms River, NJ

7. La Scala Italian Pastry Shop – Toms River

For families who love traditional Italian desserts, La Scala Italian Pastry Shop is a local favorite.

The bakery is known for its Italian pastries, cannoli, specialty cakes, cheesecakes, and assorted desserts. Its selection of sweet treats makes it another place to consider when putting together your Thanksgiving dessert table.

Location: 1231 Route 166, Toms River, NJ

8. Big Apple Bakery – Manahawkin

Big Apple Bakery is another Southern Ocean County destination for freshly baked treats.

The bakery offers traditional baked goods, Italian-American pastries, cookies, pies, and specialty cakes. Whether you’re shopping for a holiday dessert or looking for something to serve alongside Thanksgiving dinner, it’s worth checking out its seasonal selection.

Location: 595 E. Bay Avenue, Stafford Township, NJ

9. Baked on the Beach – Surf City

Located on Long Beach Island, Baked on the Beach is a scratch-made bakery known for its fresh pastries, cookies, cinnamon buns, cakes, and pies.

The bakery offers rotating selections and special-order baked goods, making it worth contacting ahead of Thanksgiving to find out what pies will be available.

Location: 2101 Long Beach Boulevard, Surf City, NJ

10. Colonial Bakery – Lavallette

Rounding out the list is Colonial Bakery in Lavallette. This longtime Jersey Shore bakery is another local stop for anyone looking to pick up fresh baked goods.

Whether you’re shopping for pastries, sweets, or something special for your holiday gathering, it’s worth checking with the bakery about its Thanksgiving offerings.

Location: 3091 Route 35, Lavallette, NJ

Don’t Wait Until the Last Minute to Order Your Thanksgiving Pies!

With Thanksgiving approaching, now is the time to start planning your dessert menu. Popular pie flavors can sell out quickly, especially during the days leading up to the holiday.

A few things to remember before placing your order:

• Order early: Contact your favorite bakery to ask about Thanksgiving preorders.
• Check the flavors: Pumpkin, apple, pecan, and cream pies are holiday favorites, but selections vary.
• Confirm pickup dates: Ask when your pies will be ready for pickup.
• Ask about specialty options: Some bakeries offer vegan or gluten-free desserts.
• Don’t forget extras: Cookies, cakes, pastries, and other treats can make your dessert table even sweeter.