
MIDDLETOWN, NJ – Middletown Township police are searching for a suspect who allegedly attempted to rob a homeowner at gunpoint while posing as a delivery person on November 14, 2026. According to police, officers responded to 57 Sidney Court following a report of an attempted robbery. The suspect reportedly approached the residence carrying a box and knocked on the front door while pretending to be a delivery person.
When the homeowner answered, the suspect allegedly produced a handgun, prompting a physical struggle. During the confrontation, the suspect dropped the weapon and fled the scene. Police later recovered the firearm and determined it was a BB gun pistol.
Officers deployed drones and K-9 tracking dogs to search the surrounding area, but the suspect remains at large.
The suspect is described as a white male in his early 20s, wearing a flannel shirt, blue jeans, and boots. He was last seen fleeing the area on foot. Investigators also received information indicating he may have left the area in a black sedan of an unknown make and model.
As part of the ongoing investigation, detectives obtained security footage showing the suspect approaching the area and running away from the scene.
Middletown police are being assisted by officers from several neighboring agencies, including the Atlantic Highlands Police Department, Highlands Police Department, Sea Bright Police Department, and the Monmouth County Sheriff’s Office. Authorities are conducting a regional search for the suspect while continuing to seek witnesses and additional evidence.
Chief Weber is urging residents to remain alert and report any suspicious activity.
Anyone who recognizes the suspect or has information that could assist investigators is asked to contact Detective Ryan Pigott of the Middletown Township Police Department at 732-615-2120.
The investigation remains ongoing, and the suspect has not yet been apprehended.