TOMS RIVER, NJ — If there’s one food New Jersey residents take seriously, it’s pizza. And in Toms River, finding a great slice is never too difficult.

From traditional New York-style pies and crispy Sicilian slices to gourmet creations loaded with unique toppings, the township has plenty of pizzerias competing for a place in the hearts of local pizza lovers.

Whether you’re planning a family pizza night, grabbing lunch or looking for a new neighborhood favorite, there are plenty of local spots worth checking out.

🍕 Toms River Pizzerias Worth Knowing

Here are several restaurants featured in local Toms River pizza directories:

1. Sal’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Located at 1606 Route 37 East, Sal’s has served the Toms River and Island Heights communities for more than 25 years. The restaurant offers pizza, pasta, subs, salads and catering.

2. Brooklyn Square Pizza

Located at 1898 Hinds Road, Brooklyn Square is known for its square pizzas and signature upside-down pies.

3. Capone’s Gourmet Pizza & Pasta

Located at 17 Washington Street, this downtown Toms River restaurant serves gourmet pizza alongside traditional Italian favorites.

4. Johnny G’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Located at 1812 Hooper Avenue, Johnny G’s offers pizza and a variety of Italian dishes for local families.

5. Attilio’s Pizza

Located at 944 Route 166, Attilio’s provides another neighborhood option for pizza lovers.

6. Charlie’s Pizza

Located at 860 Fischer Boulevard, Charlie’s serves traditional pizza and Italian-American favorites.

7. Slice House

Located at 177 Route 37 West, Slice House offers New York-style pies, specialty pizzas, Sicilian options and creative combinations.

8. Pondrelli’s Pizza & Kitchen

Located at 1500 Route 37, Pondrelli’s serves traditional and specialty pizzas along with a selection of Italian dishes.

9. PaciDough’s Pizza Joint

Located at 312 Atlantic City Boulevard, PaciDough’s has developed a following for its sourdough pizza, specialty combinations and creative menu.

10. STR Pizza

Located at 399 Dover Road, STR Pizza offers traditional favorites alongside creative specialty slices.

The Competition Is Heating Up

Toms River’s pizza scene continues to offer something for nearly every taste.

Some residents prefer a classic thin-crust cheese pie, while others enjoy Grandma-style pizza, upside-down pies, specialty toppings or traditional Italian combinations.

With so many choices, the question isn’t whether you can find pizza in Toms River. It’s which pizzeria deserves your next visit.