Toms River takes pizza seriously old‑school slices, creative toppings, and neighborhood spots where the staff knows your order by heart. After digging through reviews, local rankings, and word‑of‑mouth favorites, here are five standout pizzerias that keep coming up when people talk about the best pizza in town.

These aren’t the only good pies in Toms River, but if you’re starting a “who’s really best?” tour, this is a strong starting lineup.

1. Pondrelli’s Pizza and Kitchen

Vibe: Warm, welcoming, and very “family‑run” in feel—people talk as much about the staff as they do about the food.

• Signature pizza style:
  Thin square “New Roman” pies, Sicilian, and classic boardwalk‑style slices. If you like a crisp, flavorful square slice, this is your spot.
• What people say:
  Commentary & reviews: Reviews highlight how the owners walk guests through every slice and sandwich, making first‑timers feel like regulars. The phrase “all of the food was amazing” shows up a lot, especially for first visits.
• Specials & standouts:
  New Roman thin square pizza, Margherita pies, garlic knots, and classic subs. Great for mixed orders—pizza plus sandwiches and salads.
• Location:
  1500 NJ‑37, Toms River, NJ
• Website:
  Search “https://pondrellispizza.com/” for menu, hours, and delivery options.

2. Slice House Pizza

Vibe: Casual, slice‑centric, and very much a “grab a slice and hang out” kind of place.

• Signature pizza style:
  NY‑style slices, upside‑down pies, Sicilian, and loaded specialty slices like bacon chicken ranch and chicken ricotta.
• What people say:
  Commentary & reviews: Regulars praise the “really great pizza and nice staff/owner,” and it’s the kind of shop people recommend when someone asks for a reliable, everyday slice.
• Specials & standouts:
  Upside‑down pizza, bacon chicken ranch, stromboli, and zeppoli stuffed with cannoli cream—a sleeper dessert hit.
• Location:
  177 NJ‑37, Toms River, NJ
• Website:
  Search “http://slicehousetr.com/” for online ordering and daily specials.

3. PaciDough’s Pizza Joint

Vibe: Neighborhood joint with a loyal following—especially for parties and catering. It’s the place people quietly recommend when they want consistently good food for a crowd.

• Signature pizza style:
  Classic Jersey pizzeria pies and personal pizzas—straightforward, satisfying, and built for repeat orders.
• What people say:
  Commentary & reviews: Reviews rave about their catered trays—meatballs, wings, vodka rigatoni, subs—and call it their “favorite place for pizza too,” which says a lot in a town with this many options.
• Specials & standouts:
  Personal pies, party trays, wings, vodka rigatoni, and subs. Ideal if you’re hosting a game night or family gathering and want pizza plus full trays.
• Location:
  312 Atlantic City Blvd, Toms River, NJ
• Website:
  Search “Pacidough Pizza Joint Menu | Get Best Deal | Order Food Online” for catering info and menus.

4. Capone’s Gourmet Pizza & Pasta

Vibe: Classic Italian‑American restaurant with generous portions and a full menu—this is more “sit down and stay awhile” than quick slice.

• Signature pizza style:
  Traditional Italian‑American pies with a focus on hearty toppings and a well‑balanced crust and sauce.
• What people say:
  Commentary & reviews: Diners highlight “everything was delicious” and “generous portions,” making it a go‑to for families and groups who want pizza plus pasta and classic Italian dishes.
• Specials & standouts:
  Gourmet pies, pasta dinners, and family‑style portions. Great if some of the table wants chicken parm or baked ziti while others stick to pizza.
• Location:
  17 Washington St, Toms River, NJ 08753
• Website:
  Search “Capone’s Gourmet Pizza & Pasta Toms River” for reservations, menus, and online ordering.

So…who really has the best pizza?

That’s the fun part—there’s no single winner.

• If you love thin square or boardwalk‑style slices: Hit Pondrelli’s.
• If you’re a slice‑shop purist: Slice House is your everyday hero.
• If you’re feeding a crowd: PaciDough’s is built for parties.
• If you want a full Italian dinner with your pie: Capone’s is the move.